표제지
머리말 / 제대식
Contents
Chapter I. Comparison of organizations 9
1. Organization chart 11
2. Overview of organizations 12
2.1. Organizations 12
2.2. Manpower 14
3. Structure of trial and appeal department 14
3.1. Qualification for administrative patent judges 14
3.2. Panel for trial and appeal 17
4. Exclusion, etc. of administrative patent judges 21
4.1. Related laws 21
4.2. Related guidelines 23
Chapter II. Comparison chart for appeal against decision of rejection 29
1. Related laws 31
1.1. Laws related to appeal request 31
1.2. Laws related to appeal formalities 31
1.3. Laws related to reconsideration by examiner before appeal(Interlocutory examination) 34
1.4. Laws related to appeal proceeding on the merits 36
1.5. Laws related to the scope of an amendment to a specification or drawings 39
2. Petitioner 42
2.1. Petitioner 42
2.2. Joint application 42
2.3. Appeal intervention 43
3. Request for appeal(reexamination) 45
3.1. Subject matter of request 45
3.2. Time frame 45
3.3. Written request for appeal 49
3.4. Fees 52
4. Formality examination 53
4.1. General 53
4.2. Change of gist 56
5. Reasons for rejection 56
6. Reconsideration by examiner before appeal(Interlocutory examination) 57
6.1. Specification or drawings for reconsideration by examiner 57
6.2. Scope of an amendment to a specification or drawings 58
6.3. Procedure of reconsideration by examiner before appeal 61
6.4. Termination of reconsideration by examiner before appeal 65
7. Appeal proceeding on the merits 67
7.1. General 67
7.2. Specification or drawings for appeal proceeding 68
7.3. Effect of examination procedure 72
7.4. Notice of grounds for rejection and an amendment 72
7.5. Divisional application in the process of appeal 76
8. Termination of appeal 77
8.1. Overview 77
8.2. Appeal decision(reexamination decision) 78
8.3. Order of appeal decision 79
8.4. Reversing and rendering decision 81
8.5. Effect of appeal decision 82
8.6. Appeal to court 83
8.7. Withdrawal of appeal 84
9. Accelerated appeal 84
9.1. Cases for accelerated appeal 84
9.2. Procedure of the accelerated appeal 88
Chapter III. Analysis Results 93
I. Comparison of Organization 95
1. Organization chart 95
2. Overview of organizations 95
3. Structure of trial and appeal department 96
4. Exclusion of administrative patent judges and the like 98
II. Comparison of appeal against decision of rejection 100
1. Relevant laws 100
2. Petitioner 101
3. Request for appeal (reexamination) 101
4. Formality Examination 103
5. Grounds for rejection 105
6. Reconsideration by examiner before appeal (Interlocutory examination) 105
7. Appeal proceeding on the merits 108
8. Termination of appeal (reexamination) 113
9. Accelerated appeal 116
Appendix - Assignment of appeal cases of JPO's trial and appeal department 118
목차
Chapter I. 심판조직 비교 129
1. 조직도 131
2. 조직현황 132
2.1. 조직 132
2.2. 인원 133
3. 심판부 구성 133
3.1. 심판관 자격 133
3.2. 심판합의체 135
4. 심판관의 제척 등 137
4.1. 관련 법령 137
4.2. 관련 지침 139
Chapter II. 거절불복심판 비교표 143
1. 관련 법령 145
1.1. 심판청구 규정 145
1.2. 방식심리 규정 145
1.3. 심사전치 규정 147
1.4. 본안심리 규정 148
1.5. 명세서 또는 도면의 보정 규정 151
2. 심판청구인 153
2.1. 심판청구인 153
2.2. 공동출원 153
2.3. 심판참가 154
3. 심판청구(재심사) 155
3.1. 청구대상 155
3.2. 청구시기 155
3.3. 심판청구서 158
3.4. 수수료 160
4. 방식심리 161
4.1. 일반 161
4.2. 요지변경 162
5. 거절이유 163
6. 심사전치 164
6.1. 심사전치 대상 164
6.2. 심사전치 시 명세서 또는 도면의 보정 범위 164
6.3. 심사전치 절차 166
6.4. 심사전치 종료 169
7. 본안심리 170
7.1. 심리일반 170
7.2. 심리대상이 되는 명세서 및 도면 171
7.3. 심사에서 한 절차의 효력 173
7.4. 심판 절차에서 거절이유 통지 및 보정 173
7.5. 심판단계에서 분할출원 가능 여부 175
8. 심판의 종결 176
8.1. 개요 176
8.2. 심결 176
8.3. 심결주문 기재방식 177
8.4. 자판을 하는 경우 178
8.5. 심결의 효과 178
8.6. 불복 179
8.7. 심판의 취하 180
9. 우선·신속심판제도 180
9.1. 대상사건 180
9.2. 우선심판 처리절차 182
Chapter III. 분석결과 185
I. 심판조직 비교 187
1. 조직도 187
2. 조직현황 187
3. 심판부 구성 188
4. 심판관 제척 등 189
II. 거절결정불복심판 비교 191
1. 관련 법령 191
2. 심판청구인 191
3. 심판의 청구(재심사) 192
4. 방식심리 194
5. 거절이유 195
6. 심사전치 195
7. 본안심리 197
8. 심판의 종료 201
9. 우선·신속심판제도 203
부록 : 일본 심판부 사건배정 205
판권기 208