Title page 1
Contents 4
Abbreviations 10
Acknowledgments 12
About the Editors 13
About the Authors 15
Preface 22
Overview 24
PART I. Business Digitalization 37
1. Unintended Consequences of Business Digitalization Among MSMEs During the COVID-19 Pandemic: The Case of the Philippines 38
1.1. Introduction 38
1.2. Philippine MSME Landscape and COVID-19 Impact 40
1.3. Empirical Method 42
1.4. Data 49
1.5. Estimation Results 55
1.6. Conclusion 61
References 63
2. Digital Lifeline? Internet Utilization and Entrepreneurial Resilience in Pandemic Times: The Case of Indonesia 66
2.1. Background 66
2.2. Literature Review 69
2.3. Methodology and Data 71
2.4. Empirical Results 76
2.5. Conclusion and Policy Implications 91
References 93
PART II. Gender-Balanced Growth 97
3. Resilience to Shocks of Micro, Small, and Medium-Sized Enterprises in Fiji 98
3.1. Introduction 98
3.2. Background and Context 102
3.3. Data and Descriptive Evidence 105
3.4. Methodology 115
3.5. Results 119
3.6. Discussion 125
3.7. Conclusion 127
References 129
Appendix 132
4. Women-Led Firms, Digital Technology Adoption, and Access to Finance in India 134
4.1. Introduction 134
4.2. Literature Review 137
4.3. Data and Variable Description 140
4.4. Methodology 146
4.5. Estimation 147
4.6. Robustness Checks 152
4.7. Conclusion and Policy Recommendations 155
References 157
Appendix A4 162
PART III. Entrepreneurship Development 163
5. What Factors Encourage the Entrepreneurial Spirit? Findings from Three Pacific Islands 164
5.1. Introduction 164
5.2. Literature Review 165
5.3. Methodology 168
5.4. Results 168
5.5. Discussion and Implications 178
5.6. Conclusion 183
References 184
6. Individual and Social Preferences of Entrepreneurs: A Study Using Experimental and Nonexperimental Data from Delhi, India 187
6.1. Introduction 187
6.2. Institutional Setting and Data 192
6.3. Artifactual Field Experiments 198
6.4. Empirical Strategy 202
6.5. Empirical Results 204
6.6. Conclusion 216
References 219
PART IV. Innovative Financing Models 223
7. Equivalence of Carbon Tax, Carbon Pricing, and Small and Medium-Sized Enterprise Green Policies 224
7.1. Portfolio Allocation by Considering Environmental, Social, and Governance Scores 224
7.2. Carbon Pricing to Regain Optimal Portfolio Allocation 229
7.3. Diversified Carbon Pricing 231
7.4. Green Bonds 233
7.5. Proposed Solution to Account for Differences 234
7.6/7.7. Small Share of Green Bonds to Total Bond Issuance 240
7.7/7.8. Comparison of Carbon Finance Instruments: Burdens and Recipients 242
7.8/7.9. Implications for Asia's Policymakers 243
7.9/7.10. Conclusion 244
References 246
8. Prospects and Challenges of Digital Invoice Financing for MSMEs in India: An Empirical Study 248
8.1. Introduction 248
8.2. Supply Chain Financing and Role of Digital Invoice Financing for MSMEs 250
8.3. Indian Experiment in Digital Invoice Financing: Some Stylized Facts 252
8.4. Tests of Hypothesis 253
8.5. Data and Methodology 258
8.6. Empirical Analysis and Findings 259
8.7. Major Findings and Recommendations 266
8.8. Concluding Remarks 268
References 270
PART V. Evidence-Based Policy Actions 274
9. Strategies and Resilience of Firms Facing Competition from the Informal Sector 275
9.1. Introduction 275
9.2. Theoretical Perspectives on Informal Sector Competition 277
9.3. Methodology 280
9.4. Data and Variables 282
9.5. Results 283
9.6. Conclusion and Policy Recommendations 292
References 294
Appendix 300
10. Designing a Country's SME Development Index Using Firm-Level Data: The Case of Thailand 308
10.1. Introduction 308
10.2. Thailand's MSME Landscape and Policy Support Measures 310
10.3. Empirical Approaches 312
10.4. Data 312
10.5. Estimation Results 315
10.6. Key Findings from Empirical Analyses and Policy Implication 342
10.7. Conclusion 344
References 345
Appendix 1. Probabilistic Principal Component Analysis Concept 346
Appendix 2. Factor Loadings Based on Probabilistic Principal Component Analysis 351
11. Conclusion: Policy Actions to Build an Optimal MSME Ecosystem 376
Tables 6 Table 1.1. Mean Attributes and Business Performance of MSMEs Using or Not Using the Internet-Based on March 2020 Samples 52
Table 1.2. Mean Attributes and Business Performance of MSMEs Using or Not Using the Internet-Based on August 2020 Samples 53
Table 1.3. Mean Attributes and Business Performance of MSMEs Using or Not Using the Internet-Based on March 2021 Samples 54
Table 1.4. Regression Results of Effects of Using the Internet on Business Performance-Based on the Samples from the March 2020 Dataset 55
Table 1.5. Regression Results of Effects of Using the Internet on Business Performance-Based on the Samples from the August 2020 Dataset 57
Table 1.6. Regression Results of Effects of Using the Internet on Business Performance-Based on the Samples from the March 2021 Dataset 58
Table 2.1. Descriptive Statistics of Entrepreneurs' Characteristics Used in Analysis 75
Table 2.2. Determinants of Internet Use: Logit Estimates 77
Table 2.3. Average Treatment Effect of the Treated of Internet Use on Entrepreneurial Resilience 79
Table 2.4. Balance Assessment Before and After Matching 81
Table 2.5. E-value of Average Treatment Effect of the Treated Estimates 85
Table 2.6. ATT of Internet Utilization on Entrepreneurial Resilience Using Unmatched Data 86
Table 2.7. Simulation-based Average Treatment Effect of the Treated of Internet Utilization on Entrepreneurial Resilience Using Matched Data 87
Table 2.8. Heterogeneous Effect of Internet Use on Entrepreneurial Resilience Across Formal and Informal Entrepreneurs 88
Table 2.9. Heterogeneous Effect of Internet Use on Entrepreneurial Resilience Across Years 91
Table 3.1. Characteristics of MSMEs by Concessional Loan Access 110
Table 3.2. Is the Enterprise Exposed to a Natural Hazard That Could Shut the Business for 4 Weeks? 114
Table 3.3. Did Concessional Loans Aid Post-Pandemic Recovery? (Ordinary Least Squares Analysis) 120
Table 3.4. Did Concessional Loans Aid Post-Pandemic Recovery? (Ordinary Least Squares Analysis-Female) 120
Table 3.5. Did Concessional Loans Aid Post-Pandemic Recovery? (Propensity Score Matching Analysis) 121
Table 3.6. Did Concessional Loans Aid Post-Pandemic Recovery? (Propensity Score Matching Analysis-Female) 121
Table 3.7. Does Past Experience with Climate Shocks Affect Enterprises' Future Responses? (Ordinary Least Squares Analysis) 123
Table 3.8. Does Past Experience with Climate Shocks Affect Enterprises' Future Responses? (Ordinary Least Squares Analysis-Female) 123
Table 3.9. Does Past Experience with Climate Shocks Affect Enterprises' Future Responses? (Propensity Score Matching Analysis) 124
Table 3.10. Does Past Experience with Climate Shocks Affect Enterprises' Future Responses? (Propensity Score Matching Analysis-Female) 124
Table 4.1. Descriptive Statistics 143
Table 4.2. Pooled Analysis of Regression Results from Ordered Probit Models 148
Table 4.3. Regression Results from Ordered Probit Models with Two Different Dependent Variables on Digital Technology Usage 150
Table 4.4. Regression Results from IVProbit Using Binary Dependent Variable Credit Constraint Dummy 154
Table 5.1. Factor Loadings and Correlation Matrices 170
Table 5.2. Key Variables and Covariates by Country (Actual Data) 172
Table 5.3. Key Variables and Covariates by Country (Standardized Data) 173
Table 5.4. Linear Regression Outputs-Attitude and Social Norms 175
Table 5.5. Linear Regression Outputs-Country Estimates 177
Table 6.1. Types of Entrepreneurs in Our Study 197
Table 6.2. Survey Timing and Data Distribution 197
Table 6.3. Intertemporal Choice Sets in the Convex Time Budget Experiment 201
Table 6.4. Socioeconomic Background of the Sample Entrepreneurs 206
Table 6.5. Responses to General Social Survey Trust Questions 207
Table 6.6. Choices in Business Management Diagnostic Test 209
Table 6.7. Estimation Results Based on the Convex Time Budget Model by Andreoni and Sprenger (2012) 213
Table 6.8. Performance and Characteristics of Sample Firms 215
Table 7.1. Rating Methods of Various Rating Agencies 226
Table 7.2. Empirical Analysis of the Relationship Between ESG Scores and Return/Risk 228
Table 7.3. Carbon Price 231
Table 7.4. Scope 1, 2, and 3 Emissions 236
Table 7.5. Examples of Credit Scoring, GHG Tax, and Green Bonds Based on GHG Emissions 238
Table 7.6. Eligible Green Project Categories 241
Table 7.7. Green Bonds as a Percentage of Overall Bond Market 242
Table 7.8. Comparison of Carbon Finance Instruments 242
Table 8.1. Independent Variable Definitions 254
Table 8.2. Descriptive Statistics 259
Table 8.3. Estimation Results of Ordinary Least Squares: Determinants of Interest Rate for Fintech Factoring Financing 260
Table 8.4. Tobit Regression: Determinants of Financier Participation in Fintech Factoring Financing 263
Table 8.5. Comparison of Empirical Results and Major Findings 266
Table 9.1. Adjusted Odds Ratio Obtained from Ordered Logistic Regression-Strategies for Firms Facing Informal Sector Competition 286
Table 10.1. MSME Data in Thailand 313
Table 10.2. Factor Loadings Based on Probabilistic Principal Component Analysis-Total Micro, Small, and Medium-Sized Enterprise Data 318
Table 10.3. Factor Loadings Based on Probabilistic Principal Component Analysis-Wholesale Trade 323
Table 10.4. Factor Loadings Based on Probabilistic Principal Component Analysis-Bangkok (Capital City) 327
Table 10.5. Factor Loadings Based on Probabilistic Principal Component Analysis-Raw Data 339
Table 11.1. New United States Tariffs and Their Potential Impact on MSME Exports in Developing Asia (as of 14 April 2025) 386
Figures 8
Figure 1. Real Gross Domestic Product Growth 33
Figure 2. MSMEs in Developing Asia and the Pacific 34
Figure 1.1. Real Philippine GDP (2000-2023) and Linear Trend Extension for 2020-2023 Based on 2000-2019 Data 41
Figure 1.2. Timeline of Quarantine Measures in the Philippines from March 2020 to May 2021 45
Figure 2.1. Comparison of Distance Before and After Matching 84
Figure 2.2. Heterogeneous Effect of Internet Use on Entrepreneurial Resilience Across Regions (Islands in Indonesia) 89
Figure 3.1. Change in Profits Relative to Expectations 108
Figure 3.2. MSME COVID-19 Responses 108
Figure 3.3. Exposure to Natural Hazards 111
Figure 3.4. Mechanisms to Recover from Natural Hazards 112
Figure 3.5. COVID-19 Analysis: Common Support Histogram 116
Figure 3.6. COVID-19 Analysis: Common Support Histogram 116
Figure 3.7. Climate Analysis: Common Support Histogram 118
Figure 3.8. Climate Analysis: Common Support Histogram 119
Figure 4.1. Credit Constraints Across Managers, 2014 and 2022 144
Figure 4.2. Firms with Technology (Website Presence), 2014 and 2022 144
Figure 4.3. Credit Constraints with Website Presence by Gender of the Manager, 2014 and 2022 145
Figure 5.1. Distribution of Attitude 169
Figure 5.2. Distribution of Social Norms 169
Figure 5.3. Scatter Plot - Association Between Attitude and Social Norms 171
Figure 7.1. Different ESG Scores by Different Rating Agencies 227
Figure 7.2. Price Evolution in Selected Emissions Trading Systems from 2018 to 2023 231
Figure 7.3. Impact of Emissions Limit on Carbon Pricing 232
Figure 7.4. Equivalence of Carbon Tax, Carbon Pricing, and Carbon Credit Rating 234
Figure 7.5. Proposed Taxation Mechanism Scope 1, Scope 2 and Scope 3: Value Chain 237
Figure 7.6. Green Finance Policies for Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises 239
Figure 8.1. Trends in MSME Financing through TReDS, 2018-2022 253
Figure 10.1. SME-DI based on Total MSME Data 317
Figure 10.2. SME-DI for Wholesale Trade 322
Figure 10.3. SME-DI for Bangkok (Capital City) 326
Figure 10.4. Manufacturing-Bangkok 331
Figure 10.5. Manufacturing-Outside Bangkok 331
Figure 10.6. Agriculture-Bangkok 332
Figure 10.7. Agriculture-Outside Bangkok 333
Figure 10.8. SME-DI on Real Variables 334
Figure 10.9. SME-DI on Financial Variables 334
Figure 10.10. Small Sample Exercises 336
Figure 10.11. SME-DI on the Firm-Year Level Raw Data (10% Randomly Chosen) 338
Figure 11.1. Growth Structure of MSMEs-Manufacturing 382
Appendix Tables 162 4. Women-Led Firms, Digital Technology Adoption, and Access to Finance in India 162
Table A4. Variable Description 162
9. Strategies and Resilience of Firms Facing Competition from the Informal Sector 300
Table A1. Descriptive Statistics 300
Table A2. Variable Descriptions 301
Table A3. Adjusted odds Ratio Obtained from Ordered Logistic Regression-External Factors Affecting Firms 302
Table A4. Adjusted Odds Ratio Obtained from Ordered Logistic Regression-Strategies for Firms in Manufacturing and Services Facing... 303
Table A5. Adjusted Odds Ratio Obtained from Ordered Logistic Regression-Strategies for Small and Medium-sized Firms Facing... 305
Table A6. Adjusted Odds Ratio Obtained from Ordered Logistic Regression-Strategies for Firms Facing Informal Sector Competition;... 306
Table A7. Adjusted Odds Ratio Obtained from Ordered Logistic Regression-Strategies for Firms Facing Informal Sector Competition;... 307
10. Designing a Country's SME Development Index Using Firm-Level Data: The Case of Thailand 352
A1. Factor Loadings (Manufacturing and Bangkok) 352
A2. Factor Loadings (Manufacturing and Outside Bangkok) 355
B1. Factor Loadings (Agriculture and Bangkok) 358
B2. Factor Loadings (Agriculture and Outside Bangkok) 361
C1. Factor Loadings (Real Variables) 364
C2. Factor Loadings (Financial Variables) 367
D1. Factor Loadings (Small Sample Exercise-50% Sample) 370
D2. Factor Loadings (Small Sample Exercise -10% Sample) 373